III - 1

PART III - INVENTION OF GUILT

1. Zero Evidence - November 2019 - page 2

2. Arrest Affidavit - December 16, 2016 - page 4

3. Cell Tower Records - December 2016 - page 9

4. Police Report - January 2017 - page 16

10. Video Not Disclosed - page 35

11. Video Timeline Impossible - page 39

12. Jacket Origin Uncertain - page 41

13. Timestamps Off 7 Minutes - page 42

14. Real Lofts Timeline - December 14, 2016 - page 45

15. Other Video - 2016, 2017, 2018, 2019 - page 48

16. Shot While Fleeing - December, 2016 - page 50

17. Smolarek Bullet Hole - December 2016 - page 54

18. Vehicle Warrant- December 19, 2016 - page 58

III - 2

1. ZERO EVIDENCE - November 2019

I started this story when I walked out of a courtroom where a 24-year old girl received two life sentences, while she

made sounds like a dog stuck with an ice pick. In the end, the only evidence was:

3) Scott Love was at Mulrenin's apartment at the same time Jackson was there, but phone and video records show

Jackson was never with Scott Love, or communicating with him at any point during the entire night.

4) James Mulrenin was out of his mind on drugs, was shot in the leg, and later went over the balcony.

5) Mandi Jackson and Scott Love used Mulrenin's credit cards together at Walmart a few hours later.

6) A gun which probably matched the bullet which shot James Mulrenin, was photographed in a drawer in Mandi's

house, next to a bra, but it is unsure who put it there.

None of the evidence listed above proves the contents of her mind. There is no evidence Mandi Jackson ever

deviated from her long and compulsive pattern, of cheating on boyfriends with old guys for money, to relieve

anxiety over paying the rent. And you will see there are dozens of items of evidence, that suggest robbing James

Mulrenin could not have been in her mind.

There was also a long pattern of Mandi's boyfriends reacting in a variety of ways, from the spectrum of ways

cheated boyfriends react. And I saw Mulrenin slip or try to slip between many broke girls and their boyfriends. So

Mulrenin also had a long pattern of exploiting vulnerable young girls.

Events took an unexpected turn when Mulrenin went over the balcony. At that point, any plans Mandi Jackson had

rob Mulrenin, she would have never wanted to use his credit cards after he unexpectedly died right in front of her. If

her boyfriend unexpectedly caught her cheating and she lost her job and never got her dancer dollars, she might let

him use the credit cards to placate him, or used them herself for stress over money. But she never could have

predicted that situation she would find herself in.

You may wonder why a jury convicted Mandi Jackson based on zero evidence. People who were there wonder the

same thing. The jurors were not very excited about the rules they were supposed to follow, but they were very

amused with their own power. And they had a good chemistry where they liked to all come together and agree with

one another. It was all about the fun parts for them, and none of the boring instructions and rules they were

supposed to follow.

III - 3

You might say peers aren't perfect, they are still the best you can hope for, and you asked for them. But the

defendant was granted no similar license, and was hammered with rules at every turn. At the same time, the

witnesses made up stories and bent facts at every step, with no shame, punishment, or remorse.

The jurors' favorite group pastime during recess, was following me around the courthouse saying "Hey, mystery

guy!" and trying to get me to talk about the case with them. The jurors talked about me among themselves, saying I

was "creepy" for telling them "don't talk to me." They asked questions about me, and were asked questions about

The jurors' second-favorite pastime was deliberating among themselves during testimony. And that is just the two

inappropriate pastimes that were visible to me. One juror had a tablet in the jury box, which she insisted she was

only using during bench conferences. A friend of the victim was allowed to sit in the jury box, inform other jurors

that she had information from the day James Mulrenin died, and say how she was certain of Mandi's guilt.

A jury like that was susceptible to gossip. And they were likely distracted by three hours of the worst coerced smear

gossip, which a bizarre technicality of the rules of evidence allows to be presented under the label of "witnesses." I

know something about this case, I have studied it for years and I am familiar with the defendant and the victim. But

the defense cannot pay me to recite what I know, and call it evidence. Not even under the sixth amendment,

according to Judge Recksiedler.

People in the courtroom, including adversaries of the defendant and/or neutral parties, were shocked with the

verdict. I won't bother naming names because they have no reason to tell you their real opinions or corroborate what

I say. It is not out of disrespect for the justice system that I write all this here. Rather, the justice system was

disrespected and corrupted to reach this verdict. And it needs to be corrected for the court, and the pursuit of justice,

to be respected.

It is not at all clear why Mandi Jackson would have needed to fill out an application to work at the Dollhouse to get

into James Mulrenin's apartment. The prosecution says Scott Love sneaked into the building, and then either went

through a door that Mulrenin frequently left unlocked, or Mandi let him in. I think he knocked. Mandi Jackson

whatever they had to, to convict Mandi Jackson. They didn't care what the truth was, they weren't even curious. At

all levels of the system, it was a concerted mission to convict the innocent regardless of the truth.

Anyone who expects he will ever get a presumption of innocence, is at risk of a rude awakening. They can just grab

you and use 100 tricks to make you look guilty and lock you up, so you will still be there when the aliens land.

There is no institution to prevent what I just described. There is no institution to guarantee you that presumption of

innocence. You tell me what that institution is, it did nothing for Mandi Jackson.

III - 4

2. ARREST AFFIDAVIT - December 16, 2016

********************************************************************************

AFFIDAVIT FOR ARREST WARRANT

On December 14, 2016 the Altamonte Springs Police Department responded to The Lofts Uptown Altamonte, 285

Officers located Mulrenin's apartment where the door as found ajar. Upon entering the apartment no one else was

found and the rear sliding door was open. On the balcony a round table was tilted towards the sliding glass door.

The Christmas net lights which previously hung on the left side of the railing were missing. There were lights on the

right side of the railing that were similar to lights that were located on the ground next to Mulrenin. A large rug in

the main room was bunched up towards the center. There was what appeared to be blood on the rug. A serrated knife

was found on the couch and suspected blood was located on the carpet, on the right portion of the couch recliner,

closest to the door and on the sliding glass door leading to the balcony. A roll of black duct tape was located

partially under the couch and a section of tape by the open glass slider balcony door and appeared to have been

wrapped around something and torn off. The tape had suspected blood on the sticky portion. Several plastic/nylon

zip ties were on the floor near the rug. There was a broken cell phone on the kitchen counter which also had

This phone number (407-879-4968) was later found connected to a male's Facebook Account, Scott Michael Love.

A search was conducted of the male's Facebook, finding the name, Mandi May Jackson as being in a relationship

with Scott Michael Love. At approximately 0459 hours on December 14, 2016. Jackson enters the apartment

complex parking garaga in what appears to be a late model black BMW. It was later learned that Jackson owns a

black 2009 BMW.

At approximately 0453 hours, surveillance footage shows a white male, later identified as Scott Love, through the

use of pictures located on Facebook, belonging to both Jackson and Love, along with the use of DAVID.

Surveillance video provided easily recognizable images, identifying both individuals as Mandi Jackson and Scott

Love.

buttons for a different floor. Love remains in the elevator for a couple of minutes and can clearly be seen using a cell

phone and doing what appears to be sending text messages and generally acting in a suspicious manner. Love then

gets back off the elevator after carefully looking up and down the hall before exiting and walks back toward unit

515. At approximately 0503 hours Love is seen on the fifth floor parking garage smoking a cigarette and reenters

the building to the fifth floor hallway and remains out of camera view.

At 0524 hours Mulrenin and Jackson are seen exiting to the fifth floor parking garage. At approximately 0527 hours

Mulrenin and Jackson return and are seen reentering the fifth floor from the parking garage.

At approximately 0637 hours a 9-1-1 call was received stating a male had fallen from the balcony. At approximately

III - 5

running from the building from the fifth floor parking garage and her vehicle leave the complex a minute later.

Detectives made contact with ORMC personnel who advised Mulrenin was on life support and would not recover.

Contact was made with his mother Dolores Mulrenin, who agreed to removed him from life support based on his

deteriorating status.

Detectives made contact with a close friend and coworker of Mulrenin who said Mulrenin was the manager of the

After multiple interviews conducted by detectives at the Dollhouse Club, it was discovered that Mandi Jackson

provided phone number 407-879-4968 to her co-worker as a way to get in touch with her. Upon researching the

phone number, law enforcement learned of several reports located in FINDER to include pawn history from July

and October of 2016 for "Scott Michael Love" and an arrest report for Love from July 2016. The phone number was

also searched in Facebook which also came back to Scott Love. A check through Love's Facebook revealed he is in

a relationship with Mandi Jackson.

Based on the aforementioned there is a probable cause to believe Jackson and Love were in contact with each other

and Jackson was in contact with Mulrenin just prior to his falling from the balcony. The manner in which Jackson is

seen leaving Mulrenin's apartment after the death shows she is running away from the crime scene. The manner in

A subpoena was submitted for Mulrenin's credit cards which indicated two transactions taking place in the amount

of $286.49 and $64.13 at Walmart #5871 on December 14, 2016 at approximately 0848 hours and 0904 hours. Det.

Baker responded to Walmart #5871 and recovered video footage that showed Love and Jackson purchasing one

Sony Playstation for $286.49 and two phones for $64.13.

At this time, due to the fact that Love and Jackson were both seen at Mulrenin's apartment during the short time

frame leading up to his death, then using his credit card at Walmart roughly two hours after his murder, there is

probable cause for their arrest for Felnoy Murder, Burglary to an Occupied Dwelling and Fraud.

Due to the fact that I have been unable to locate Mandi May Jackson for a physical arrest, I am requesting that a

SPRAGUE: Witnesses said Mulrenin left with more than $2500 cash.

I have seen a 21-year-old girl arrested and held without bond, I have seen every deposition and witness statement, I

have seen two trials, and I have never heard from anyone who witnessed Mulrenin leave with more than $2500

cash. Did Sprague throw away this person's witness statement?

SPRAGUE: Mulrenin was a good target for robbery because of his money.

According to Sprague there were two customers in the club who had much more money than Mulrenin, were

III - 6

Mandi's real name, and probably had more reputation risk from reporting they brought home and were robbed by a

stripper. Every strip club, every night, has a customer who is richer and more desperate than a strip-club manager.

SPRAGUE: Mulrenin's money clip was not found in his home.

Yes, he went over the balcony with it. All that was left at his autopsy was his belt.

SPRAGUE: They used Mulrenin's cards at Walmart.

They did not use his cash at Walmart. When you have a 52-year-old man with viagra and a 21-year-old stripper, it

would be more surprising if there weren't some credit card use at the end of it. According to Mulrenin's co-workers,

Mulrenin blasted $20k on two customers' credit cards that night who didn't even get sex.

They found Jackson and Mulrenin's DNA on the same straw. I don't think it was a straw that put Mulrenin's DNA in

Jackson's mouth. So to Mandi, she is within the ethics of her and Mulrenin's profession to go shopping. And more

urgently, given she just lost her job. Even so, it was Love who started the credit-card use by buying something

many other uses for duct tape, or it wouldn't be sold at every store. Sprague seems to at least admit this vague

possibility. I am confident the carpet was bundled up by Love in an effort to find the bullet or get rid of the blood.

Sprague should be totally familiar with people trying to get rid of evidence. I challenge anyone to cause an area rug

to be pulled from under a sofa and become folded up like the one photographed, through any type of wrestling.

Now let's look at how Sprague imagines evidence of collusion when there is none:

SPRAGUE: Love was clearly seen using a cellphone and texting, implying Jackson and Love were in contact.

Love was never seen using a cellphone, never seen texting. Evidence is Jackson and Love used the same phone

SPRAGUE: Jackson and Love were "in a relationship" on facebook, meaning they would be likely to collude.

Jackson was a stripper. So being "in a relationship" means nothing. Their being "in a relationship" indicates how

Love might react to Mandi stripping and cheating on him, more than it indicates they would collude or Mandi would

choose Love over Mulrenin.

Now let's look at evidence this wasn't a planned robbery:

SPRAGUE: Mandi Jackson provided her real non-stripper name and phone number so co-worker Neisha Cintron

could get in touch.

III - 7

If police talked to this co-worker Neisha Cintron, they should also know the last thing Mandi did before leaving,

was buy a stripper dress to wear to work the next day. And Cintron observed Jackson and Mulrenin to have an

unusually close working relationship early in the night, and even kissing, which there is some video of.

SPRAGUE: All this was seen on video.

Both Love and Jackson must be walking and driving in front of cameras without hesitation, for Sprague to see all

SPRAGUE: The first thing Love bought was a phone.

This does not seem like a premeditated or planned purchase, but a purchase in response to the problem of not being

able to call or text his cheating girlfriend all night. It seems to indicate Love was not coordinating or colluding with

Mandi, but just the opposite. He had a problem communicating with Mandi, an inability to do so, while she was in

Mulrenin's apartment.

In his affidavit, Sprague wants you to make a tenuous "felony murder" connection between the accidental death of

James Mulrenin, and Mandi Jackson being guilty of first degree murder. But they have never provided the audio of

the 911 call, or described what that audio says. They are not interested in the most immediate and best description of

The original evidence used to charge Mandi with murder, fits much better with a stripper with a sugar daddy, and a

jealous boyfriend. She is forced by the accidental death of her sugar daddy to return to her jealous boyfriend, and

placate him by allowing him to make purchases with the credit cards of the sugar daddy she just fucked.

So is Sprague crooked, or is he just stupid? I think he started out stupid, and became crooked.

There was another piece of evidence, a hand-drawn floor plan of an apartment, which was found in Mandi's car.

During a video interview of a witness from Dollhouse, Sprague characterized this hand-drawn floor plan as

evidence that Mandi and Scott "had it all planned out." He said they were very smart - the floor plan - but they were

also very stupid - doing it all on camera - which really just means his narrative makes no sense.

could keep her dog. And the labels on the apartment floor plan were "master" and "spare" not "cash" and "hide."

Another thing which Sprague hallucinated, is that nobody at Dollhouse knew Mandi Jackson, she came in from the

night as a complete stranger. In reality, the strip club community in Orlando is small. There were people in

Dollhouse who had known Mandi for a long time. But I will get to that more later.

Detective Sprague had just set the world spinning with news that a stripper had murdered her boss. He had very

much put himself on the spot by doing so. During Love's police interview, Sprague characterized himself as not very

bright, but very determined.

.

III - 8

not actually texting. When Sprague began to realize he didn't actually have solid evidence for the alleged crime, he

worked to manufacture evidence to pressure Mandi to say Scott did it. All the search warrants in this case were

rubber-stamp fishing expeditions, and none of them were a search for the truth.

Sprague was apparently raised by wolves, or at least in another country, or maybe just in Seminole County. He

thinks where Mandi's right to keep private what she does with a guy begins, is where his mandate to invent

unfounded criminal allegations about her begins.

what do we do?" The older, more honest Lieutenant Murphy just shrugged, and said oh well, that's what I expected.

But Sprague got emotional, and went into a panic he would be exposed as ineffective. He started faking evidence.

Because he would rather break the law than let someone else win.

For catching the world's slowest bunny, and making up some nonsense about her, Sprague was given LEO of the

year. In some ways Sprague is like Mulrenin. They are both mediocre men, whose self esteem was propped up at the

expense of a young girl. Mandi Jackson is like a dog who jumps into the truck of a dog catcher who can't catch

anything, to make him feel good about himself.

In Steinbeck's Tortilla Flat, they gave hapless dog catcher Tall Bob Smoke some dogs to put in his truck to look

girls.

I was always ashamed of what people might say if they found out I was taking advantage of a young girl. They

made this guy Sprague LEO Of The Year for it.

III - 9

3. CELL TOWER RECORDS - December 2016

Home - 116 pings (29 hours)

Stars/Dollhouse - 104 pings (26 hours)

Rachel's - 23 pings

Tuesday - 5 pings (Mulrenin dies)

Sprague's entire narrative of what happened, was founded on the hallucination that Mandi was some mystery girl

nobody knew. She came in from the night, robbed the manager, and vanished. If Mandi was in the same social circle

as Mulrenin, it would lead to an entirely different take on what happened. What is incredible, is how Sprague

defended his hallucination against all evidence to the contrary, to the point of even correcting witnesses who said

otherwise.

The records from the phone company included a week of tower pings from Mandi's phone. The T-Mobile witness at

maybe when she switched towers. Four pings on one tower is possibly more than an hour. One ping each, on four

towers driving up I-4, is probably less than an hour.

It was easy to tell when each day started and ended, because Mandi would spend a few hours at the tower by her

house. Then she would run a morning errand or something and hit a few nearby towers one time each. Then she

would return home for a few pings. And this is where it got interesting. Every day she would then head over to Chris

Dahl's house in the afternoon or evening, before spending all night at the strip clubs, and returning home. Chris

Dahl's house is across a pond from the Stars and Dollhouse, so the towers are adjacent.

I used Google maps to make an animated map that really brought the cell tower pings to life, and made clear sense

Remember, Mandi was supposed to be a stranger whom no one at the strip clubs knew. But her Dollhouse

application said she worked at Rachel's for an extended period. Rachel's had the same owner and managers as

Dollhouse. Mulrenin originally worked at Rachel's and still sometimes went there. Some people still knew Mulrenin

as the manager from Rachel's, Rachel's North, or Stars. His building manager Michelle Ervin said he worked at

Stars. Dollhouse and Stars are run as a single business, paying the door fee at one gets you into the other. Employees

work at both on different days. People who go to strip clubs are like me, we go to all the strip clubs.

In fact, Mandi spent more time at strip clubs owned by the Veigles that week, than at her own home. She spent 35

hours at Veigle strip clubs that week, or 139 cell tower pings. Most of those were at Stars/Dollhouse, 26 hours or

104 pings, both places where Mulrenin worked. And she spent only 29 hours or 116 pings at home on Arbor Ridge

III - 16

4. POLICE REPORT - January 2017

Report of Investigation

1/10/2017

Ben Sprague

printed 01/25/2017 14:04

however due to the severity of his injuries he was later transported to Orlando Regional Medical Center (ORMC).

Mulrenin suffered multiple injuries from the fall and a deep wound to the back of his left thigh which appeared to be

a very deep stab wound or gunshot wound. Det. Ronnie Baker was tasked with staying with Mulrenin throughout

his transport from FHA to ORMC.

Officers located Mulrenin's apartment (Unit 515) where the door was found ajar. Upon entering the apartment no

one else was found inside and the rear sliding door was open. On the balcony a round table was tilted towards the

sliding glass door. The Christmas net lights which previously hung on the left side of the railing were missing. There

were lights on the right side of the railing that were similar to lights that were located on the ground next to

Mulrenin. A large rug in the main room was bunched up towards the center. There was what appeared to be blood on

Mulrenin. Crime Scene Investigator Alison Smolarek later located a projectile on the floor underneath Mulrenin's

leather sectional couch on an additional search of Mulrenin's apartment (12/15/2016). The couch had a small

puncture in the mid-section, consistent with that of a fired projectile. Upon further inspection of the apartment, CSI

Smolarek located roughly thirteen thousand dollars in US currency, in the locked balcony closet. The money was

located in a cardboard box which will be submitted into evidence. Please see her narrative for details pertaining to

the evidence collected in Mulrenin's apartment.

At approximately 0805 hours, Det. Athaide, OFC Uzzi and I made contact with a resident in unit 415, which is

directly underneath Mulrenin's apartment. The resident identified himself as Jerome Ashcroft and stated the

following:

Det. Athaide was tasked with obtaining closed circuit video surveillance footage that was provided by the Lofts at

Uptown Altamonte.

Det. Athaide was able to review video footage which indicated Mulrenin entered the parking garage of the Lofts at

Uptown. Mulrenin is observed driving his dark colored Chrysler 300 and using his proximity card at 0429 hours on

12/14/2016 to gain entry. Mulrenin parks his vehicle on the second floor and travels up to his apartment located on

the fifth floor. At 0449 hours, he returns to elevator A and takes it to the first floor service bay door. Mulrenin is seen

on elevator A using his cellphone and carrying his lanyard that has his keys and proximity card attached to it.

Mulrenin exits on the first floor and walks in the direction of Uptown Boulevard.

III - 17

Three minutes after Mulrenin exits elevator A on the first floor, an unknown male later identified as Scott Michael

Love (DOB 1/21/1986), is seen wearing a light colored hat, blue jeans and a sweatshirt with the words "Don't Tread

On Me" on the back. Love is carrying a black bag, and observed on the closed circuit surveillance footage on the

ground floor of the apartment complex parking garage, attempting to open the same elevator door Mulrenin exited

from. Due to Love not having a key card to access the elevator he is not able to get into the elevator, whereupon he

locates a set of steel freight doors which were left open because of a non-functioning latch.

exits the elevator and heads in the direction of Mulrenin's apartment.

At 0457 hours until 0500 hours, Love reenters the same elevator on fifth floor but this time only pushes the close

door button and remains in wait.

At 0459 hours, Mulrenin and Jackson are seen entering the building from the fifth floor garage door. In this video,

Jackson appeared to have a large tattoo on her right arm which was later confirmed upon contact.

At 0500 hours, Love peeks his head out of the elevator door, then walks in the direction of Mulrenin's apartment.

At 0643 hours, Jackson is seen running out of the fifth floor hallway door into the parking garage. Then roughly two

minutes later, Jackson's back BMW is seen leaving the parking garage.

The video surveillance provided by the Lofts at Uptown Altamonte will be attached to this report.

Lt. Murphy and I went to Orlando Regional Medical Center and made contact with Det. Baker, who was standing

by in emergency room 411. Det. Baker stated he was told by medical staff that Mulrenin had multiple leg fractures,

a deep laceration to the back left thigh, and trauma to the head. I observed Mulrenin in emergency room 411 with

multiple nurses tending to his care. He was unresponsive and unable to breath on his own so the assistance from a

respiratory device was required. In the attempt to gain access to his cellular phone to try and determine his last

balcony in the attempt to take his own life. Mellinger has never known Mulrenin to experience or have suicidal

thoughts and this incident seemed very suspicious. Mellinger explained she does not remember Mulrenin having

any enemies that would try and kill him.

Mellinger advised on December 13, 2016 the Dollhouse Club "had a good night." She further advised there were at

least two individuals that spent over $20,000.00 at the club along with significant business from other patrons.

According to witnesses, Mulrenin left the club with a substantial amount of money in cash totaling upwards of

$2500. Witnesses also stated that Mulrenin always carried his money in a money clip. No money clip or wallet was

located at his home.

III - 18

Blossom Trail, Orlando, Florida 32839. Garcia stated the following.

Garcia said he did not work last night but remembers someone talking about a new female dancer who came in

looking for Mulrenin. Garcia attempted to locate the video surveillance of the female from the previous night, but

stated he would need to have his technician recover the footage at a later time. Det. Baker was later able to retrieve

the entire DVR from the Doll House and submit it into property and evidence. Garcia also advised that later that

night the female entertainers, along with valet staff and other employees would be in to help identify the female

from last night who drove the black BMW!" Little Mike stated he believed the Doll House had documentation of

the female because he knew she filled out an application to dance at the club. The Doll House staff could not locate

the application, but assured me that an application was filled out by the unknown female. Next, we made contact

with Marc Gorewitz (Valet) and showed him the image and video of the male and female from the Lofts

surveillance footage. Marc stated he recognized the female from last night because he valet parked her black BMW.

Gorewtiz said at one point the female told him, "I have the black BMW." Gorewitz advised he would come to the

Altamonte Springs Police Department at a later time and complete a recorded sworn statement.

The Doll House staff attempted to locate the female's application for employment, but was unable to find it at that

time. Lt. Murphy and I were approached by a female dancer identified as Neisha Cintron also known as "Catalina",

Intelligence Office MPO Dean and relayed him the information I was given by Cintron. After a few minutes, MPO

Dean provided a name of Mandi Jackson DOB 05/19/1995. MPO Dean sent a picture of Jackson with a male later

identified as Scott Love. The picture sent by MPO Dean was a picture taken from Facebook with Jackson and Love

together. Cintron observed the picture and stated she was the same female seen at the Doll House last night.

We again spoke with Gorewitz and showed him the new photograph that MPO Dean found of Jackson. Gorewitz

immediately was able to positively identify Jackson as the same female seen driving the black BMW lastr night at

the Doll House.

Lt. Murphy and I left the Doll House and attempted to contact Jackson at several different address within Orange

On December 15, 2016 Lt. Murphy, CSI Smolarek and I went back to Mulrenin's apartment. While conducting

another search of his belongings, we were able to locate a fired projectile underneath the couch in the living room. A

puncture hole was observed in the middle section of the couch, which is consistent to where the projectile was

found. Also, Mulrenin's checkbook was obtained and with the help from Investigator Smalt with the Seminole

County Sheriff's Office, a subpoena was obtained for Mulrenin's account activity. Please see CSI Smolarek's and

Inv. Smalt's narrative.

On December 16, 2016 information was returned reference the subpoena that was submitted a day prior for

III - 19

approximately 0848 hours and 0904 hours. Det. Baker responded to Walmart #5871 and recovered video footage

that showed Love and Jackson purchasing one Sony Playstation for $286.49 and a phone for $64.13 using

Mulrenin's credit card. In Wal-Mart's surveillance video Jackson was observed wearing the same pull over

sweatshirt that Love was seen wearing in the Lofts video surveillance footage.

While Det. Baker and CSI Annabelle Arciniega were recovering the video from the above transaction, they were

advised of a second purchase at the Walmart located at 3838 South Semoran Boulevard, Orlando, Florida. Det.

It was discovered that on December 15th 2016, at approximately 1215 hours, Jackson and Love entered the Value

Pawn #B1121 located at 6615 E Colonial Drive, Orlando, Florida 32807. Jackson pawned/sold an XBOX one

console and received $160 for the transaction. She also pawned/sold a Sony PlayStation console and received $175

for the transaction. Jackson received a total of $335 from the pawn shop under ticket number 75215. Det. David was

advised by Value Pawn staff that Jackson purchased an engagement ring with the funds she was provided from the

recent fraudulent transaction. Det. David later retrieved the video footage and recovered the appropriate pawn

broker transaction forms. Please see Det. David's narrative.

A subpoena was written by Det. Simmonds for Mulrenin's subscriber information and historical phone records

Arrest warrants were written for both Love and Jackson. The warrants were signed by the Honorable Judge

McIntosh of the 18th Circuit in Seminole County on December 16th 2016. Through certain investigative techniques,

Jackson and Love along with Jackson's black BMW were located at 10389 Arbor Ridge Trail, Orlando, Florida.

I made contact with FDLE Task Force Agent Nuzzi and Orange County Deputy Sheriff Degraw at the above

address. They advised both Jackson and Love were apprehended while inside the black BMW that was parked in

front of the residence. I observed Jackson, handcuffed and sitting on a chair. Love was handcuffed and in the back

of an Orange County Sheriff's vehicle. I looked through the windshield of Jackson's BMW and saw a credit card

belonging to James Mulrenin in plain view on the center console.

mornings.

Tri-County Towing arrived and transported Jackson's black BMW to the Seminole County Sheriff's Office Forensics

garage bay. Det. Athaide and CSI Arciniega took pictures of the vehicle before it was removed from the scene. They

followed behind the vehicle during the entire transport.

Lt. Murphy and I had Love and Jackson transported to the nearest Orange County Sheriff's Office substation for a

recorded interview.

First, we made contact with Jackson and advised her of her Miranda Warning. Jackson waived her rights and agreed

III - 20

if Jackson was ever in Alatomnte Springs last week. Jackson responded, "No." Jackson then requested to speak with

legal counsel. Jackson was transported to the Orange County Jail for processing.

Next, we made contact with Love and conducted a recorded interview. Love was read his Miranda Warning. Love

waived his rights and agreed to speak with us. I asked Love is he was familiar a guy named Jim/James Mulrenin.

Love responded, "No." I explained that Mulrenin lived at the Lofts apartment complex and Love said he was

familiar with it. I asked if he has ever been to the Lofts and he said he has in the past to do work. I asked specifically

sweatshirt that stated, "Don't tread on me" on the back. Love denied it being him.

Lt. Murphy showed Love still shots from Walmart of him and Jackson. Love stated it was Jackson but not him.

Upon further speaking with Love, he requested to speak with legal counsel. Love was transported to the Orange

County Jail for processing. A copy of the interview will be attached to this report.

A search warrant for 10389 Arbor Ridge Trail was written by Det. Van Cleave and signed by the Honorable Orange

County Circuit Court Judge, Faye Allen. The following items were located inside Jackson and Love's bedroom in

the house at 10389 Arbor Ridge Trail, Orlando Florida.

= "Signature" brand blue jeans - located on the floor in front of bed

- Black Samsung Smart phone - located on top left corner of bed

- New Men's Camo boots - located on the floor to the left of bed

- Box of Metro PCS Smartphone - located in a cubby left of the bed

- One Smith and Wesson .38 Spec. Revolver (J73843) - located in top left drawer of brown dresser

-the Smith and Wesson .38 had four live rounds inside cylinder

-one round and casing missing from cylinder

- "Ralph Lauren blue jeans - located on floor to the left of bed

- Debit Card belonging to Mandi Jackson - located in cosmetic bag on top of brown dresser

- Pawn Slip - located in bedroom closet

- Passport for Mandi Jackson - located on top right drawer in dresser

- Receipt for cell phone - located in bedroom trash can

- Straw hat - located in the bedroom closet

- Black flip style cell phone with charger - located in the end table to right of bed

- "Dollhouse / Stars" long advertisement card - On top of clothes to right of bed

The above items were recovered by CSI Smolarek and submitted into property and evidence. Please see CSI

Smolarek's narrative. D/S Degraw with the Orange County Sheriff's Office assisted with the Investigation until we

left the residence.

III - 21

Mulrenin's autopsy. The preliminary investigation revealed that Mulrenin sustained a gunshot wound to his left leg

that has a corresponding exit wound. It was also determined that Mulrenin had a lacerated brain stem, hemorrhage

all over his brain, neck fracture (c-6), hemorrhage on the spinal cord ner neck, bruised lungs, both femurs broken,

with other fractures on both lower legs.

On December 20 2016, Detective Simmonds applied for and was granted a lawful search warrant for Mandi

Jackson's BMW. The warrant was granted and signed by the Honorable M.E. Herr of the Seminole County.

- Pair of Charlotte Russe black wedges

- Pair of Herman Survivor Brown boots

- Wallet belonging to Scott Love

- Multiple credit cards belonging to James Mulrenin

- Walmart Receipts

- Brown camo wallet

- Tracfone box, phone and papers

- IPhone cell phone

- Samsung tablet

- Title and registration and bill of sale for vehicle

- Cool pad cellphone

- Two Cobra walkie talkies

- Piece of paper with writing

- Paycheck stubs

- Three plastic gloves with suspected blood

- Plastic booties, plastic gloves, zip ties and duct tape

- Plastic container with unknown substance, plastic baggies and powder substance

- Receipts

- Piece of cardboard with hand drawn map

the address of 10389 Arbor Ridge Trail, the evidence collected inside Jackson's vehicle and the body of James

Mulrenin, the following events took place during the time frame of 12/13/2016 and 12/20/2016.

James Mulrenin was working at his job at the Doll House on the night of December 13th 2016 according to

numerous co-workers and video surveillance. Mandi Jackson enhtered the Doll House on the same night, filled out

an application and waited for several hours to speak with Mulrenin. Jackson was seen by several Doll House

employees and had a converstion with Neisha Cintron and exchanged numbers that ultimately led to the discovery

of who she was. After working that night it was verified through Mulrenin's cell phone records that he and Jackson

had communicated through text messages from 0321 hours to 0444 hours on December 14th 2016.

III - 22

Mulrenin arrived home from work at roughly 0430 hours on December 14th 2016, and is seen on video footage

walking out of his apartment near 0500 hours and meeting with Jackson. Jackson is seen using Mulrenin's proximity

card to enter the Lofts at Uptown garage in her registered 2009 Black BMW. They park on the fifth floor parking

garage at the same time Scott Love is seen sneaking into the Lofts at Uptown through and unlocked metal service

door. Scott Love uses the elevator and travels up tp the fifth floor where Mulrenin's unit is located. Love pushes the

"close door" button during the same time frame as Mulrenin and Jackson enter the building from the fifth floor

parking garage. As Mulrenin and Jackson pass by the elevator, Love is seen peaking his head out then walks in the

gunshot wound to the back of the leg. After the shot, Mulrenin is screaming and runs to the balcony because that is

the only place left to flee. In the attempt to try and save his life, he goes over the rail and tries to grab the bottom of

the railing to swing to the balcony underneath, but falls to his death.

During this time witnesses Songer and Smith, hear the initial yelling from Mulrenin, then a hear gunshot, then see

him go over the rail. A 911 call is placed indicating a male fell or jumped out of a fifth floor balcony. Within a

couple minutes of officers arriving on scene, Jackson is seen exiting the building from the fifth floor into garage in a

hurry. A minute later her vehicle is seen exiting the complex, never to return.

At approximately 0730 hours, detectives arrive on scene and locate black duct tape with suspected blood on it, a

Mulrenin's credit cards to purchase fraudulent items. Another hour after that, Jackson and Love are seen on Walmart

video entering another Walmart and purchasing other items with Mulrenin's credit cards.

Later that night, when Lt. Murphy and I make contact with Doll House staff, several employees verify Jackson is

the same female seen on the Lofts at Uptown's video footage as the same female who was inside the Doll House

looking for James Mulrenin the night before (12/13/2016).

On December 15th 2016, Jackson and Love are observed and captured on CCTV from the Value Pawn Shop, selling

some of the same items they purchased with Mulrenin's credit cards the day before at Walmart.

four months. Inside the residence and vehicle were credit cards belonging to Mulrenin, zip ties, suspected blood on

plastic booties and plastic gloves, a firearm with one round missing, similar duct tape as the kind found in

Mulrenin's apartment, Doll House application, pawn slips, jeans, "don't tread on my sweatshirt" like the one seen on

video surveillance at the Lofts, straw hat, gold Nixon watch that was later identified as the same watch Mulrenin

wears at work and other miscellaneous items that would indicated Jackson and Love knew or had seen Mulrenin

within the past few weeks.

Upon completion of this investigation and all the facts found herein, I found probable cause to charge Mandi May

Jackson and Scott Michael Love with one cound of Felony Murder per F.S.S. 782.04(1)(a)(2); Burglary Occupied

per F.S.S. 810.02(3a); and Fraud per F.S.S. 817,.539(2).

III - 23

5. VIDEO GENERAL APPEARANCE - December 2016

The video clips from Mulrenin's Lofts apartments prove three things:

1) Mandi Jackson was an invited guest by a Lofts resident, Scott Love was not.

3) Police screwed around with the video, probably both a) to hide what really happened, and b) to try to show a

plan, between two people who were never together, who were never in communication, and who were probably

both acting against the wishes of the other, as couples often do when the rent is late.

Everyone sees Scott go into the building without being invited in by a resident. And there were no phone calls or

any other type of communication with Mandi when he was not with her. Scott did not have a phone, he bought one

first thing the next day.

I grew up before cellphones. Today, I would never participate in a plan with a separate person at a strange location,

without a cellphone. Mandi has never known a world without cellphones. It is inconceivable that she would design a

Scott showed up with no plan how to get in. Even though someone just swiped the freight door and it would have

been unlocked, Scott tried the freight elevator. Not even residents can open the freight elevator from the outside.

Once inside, Scott is seen wandering around in circles, and smoking, like he still has no plan or idea what to do

next.

When you see Scott on video at The Lofts, you ask the question what is he there for? Mandi Jackson was accused of

robbery, meaning taking something from a person by force. But the prosecution then shows Mulrenin had some cash

stashed in a box, with the idea that somehow Mandi knew about it before police found it, and went there to take it.

Cash stashed in a box that you know about does not have to be taken by force. Mandi can grab it and walk out when

confidence to make an elaborate plan to get it? Suppose Mulrenin told her "I have cash in a box hidden in my

house." Would she believe him enough to set up an elaborate plan to get it? She would have to have seen it herself

to go through so much.

Mandi spends two hours at Mulrenin's apartment drinking vodka. Does she have any reason to expect Mulrenin will

throw her out before she gets a chance to steal something inside his one-bedroom apartment? Mandi is there for two

hours, longer than the run time of the movie "Die Hard." But she leaves without taking the cash, without disturbing

any bed covers, boxes, cabinets, drawers, or storage areas, and without even taking the drugs in plain sight which

presumably she has been using.

III - 24

estimate she has been into more than 100 guys apartments and hotel rooms. Her pimp never went into the hotel

rooms. Mandi is perfectly comfortable in an apartment with Mulrenin, and trusts herself way more than Scott, who

works in paving and has never even been to a hotel. Mandi has been years in rooms with old men making small talk

about her cats, sitting around while guys are in the shower, drinking drinks, smoking on the balcony, eating the free

cookie, making the guys comfortable. Mandi has been years walking out of guys' rooms with cash. You might say it

is the only thing she knows how to do. If she wants to steal from Mulrenin, she only needs to do it a little different

this time, and take all the cash instead of just what the guy wants to give her. It is certainly something her years have

assumed uselessness of her own boyfriend. The plan is always "you wait outside while I go make us some money."

If Mandi wanted a boyfriend who did things to make money, there are many out there. Strippers want instead to feel

needed and be the provider.

Maybe Mandi doesn't want to be accused of stealing, by someone who is in her social circle. So she doesn't want to

be in Mulrenin's apartment when something gets stolen. She could easily fix that by going home with any of 10,000

richer guys just in Orlando, who are not in her social circle. She can walk down OBT, or place an ad on backpage,

pick a guy with a nicer car or house than Mulrenin, and show up totally anonymous.

But if her idea is to distract Mulrenin so Scott can enter and leave while Mulrenin is not home, the video doesn't fit

And if her plan is to have Scott go in and out when Mandi brings Mulrenin out to the garage later, as suggested by

police, then why does Mandi supposedly go back in and stay there for another 80 minutes after she brings Mulrenin

out to the garage? Wouldn't Mandi immediately start trying to distract Mulrenin when she gets to The Lofts, and

then immediately leave to meet up with Scott and regroup to find out if he got in?

Mulrenin goes out at least twice, first to meet Mandi at the curb, second with her in the garage. If both those failed,

Mandi would need to go out and talk to Scott, and either leave or try again immediately. Whatever was going to

happen, it would have happened success or failure in under an hour. And then Mandi would leave to meet up with

Scott.

There is no reason for Mandi to leave the apartment to let Scott in, as suggested by police. She would want to be

there when Scott comes in. But given Scott has no phone or any way to communicate with Mandi, they are not

going to have Scott wait 90 minutes with no communication before coming in. Scott is not seen looking at or

wearing a watch, or anything that tells time, on all the Lofts video.

When Mandi comes back from the garage with Mulrenin, she appears to put out a cigarette carefully. She then looks

at it, and throws it away. It looks like she is trying to put it out and save it, so she can light it again when she gets to

Mulrenin's apartment. Why would a girl about to do armed robbery be preoccupied with saving a half-smoked

cigarette?

III - 25

taped him up to stop the bleeding, and then just sat and watched him for 80 minutes. If you think Scott went in right

at the beginning, then spent 80 minutes in there without opening any boxes or cabinets, that makes even less sense.

The run time of the movie "Dog Day Afternoon" was two hours and five minutes. But at least in "Dog Day

Afternoon" they made some phone calls. No armed robbery in the history of man takes two hours.

Mulrenin's closet and storage areas were not disturbed in any way, in Smolarek's pictures. Storage boxes still sit

packed on the top shelf, nobody took them down and emptied them. Nobody lifted the mattress to check under it.

Mandi smokes weed, I have no doubt weed is what she was in there for. It is not disputed that Mulrenin was doing

cocaine that night, so Mandi would know the cocaine and $20 bill are there. Given two hours, and knowing where

the weed and cocaine are, she did not take them.

For a guy who plans an armed robbery, Scott spends a lot of time standing in front of cameras. The next day at

Walmart, when he really does want to go incognito, he ditches the paving hat for a baseball cap. At Lofts he is never

seen checking his gun on video, he is never seen putting on gloves as alleged. He spends time smoking in plain view

in an open area. He carries his bag behind like an afterthought, not in front like someone who plans to take items out

and use them.

Never in the history of armed robbery, do armed robbers hang around for two hours. Either they were in there for

two hours not stealing, or they waited two hours to start stealing, for no reason. Or maybe the reality is they stayed

there for two hours and never started a robbery. There was waiting going on. But it was simply Scott waiting for

Mandi to come out. And Mandi was not in there impatient to steal, but doing cocaine without a care in the world. Or

passed out drunk, or passed out from her anxiety medicine, which was normal for her.

And eventually Scott ran out of patience, or the sun was coming up and he needed to go to work. Or people leaving

for work acted suspicious of him and made him uncomfortable, who knows. Maybe he was listening in the hall, and

thought he heard Mandi in distress.

became witnesses.

Mandi knows and could have predicted this, from the time the guys wouldn't ler her out of the hotel room. She and

her friend Toni had to scream, they knew to scream. And when they did, security came running. Mandi told me the

second week I met her, that in hotels and apartments, even a 100-pound girl is safe from being robbed because

everyone can hear you scream. You can look on adultsearch.com today, and see girls charge $200 for incall and

I also know Mandi told her lawyer in confidence, that she did not tell Scott to come in there. When Mandi finally

agreed to let me pay for lawyer Carrie Rentz, Carrie went over to the jail one time and talked to Mandi about what

III - 32

8. VIDEO TIMESTAMPS DELETED

The original 18 clips provided by police had no time or date information whatsoever, except the files were created

and modified on December 21, 2016 from around 8 AM to 10 AM. Clip 10 of Jackson and Mulrenin driving into the

garage, was created before clip 9 of Love getting onto the freight elevator. There was a 42-minute gap from when

clip 5 of Mulrenin going down the freight elevator was made, until the next set of clips was made, supposedly

multiple police were independent witnesses who reviewed and confirmed the times of each clip, before deleting the

times from the video for no reason.

“Athaides Notes.pdf” modified December 16, 2016 10:21:04 AM

“Lofts Video Review by Dean.docx” modified December 16, 2016 10:21:24 AM